Criminal Hearts (1996)

SC-0317
Director: Dave Payne
Genre: Action, Crime, STV, Thriller
Tagline: “They were strangers when they met. Now, they're partners in crime.”
Rarity:
Critical Salvage
(12 Letterboxd written reviews)

Quick Synopsis

An aspiring actress traveling across the Southwest to confront her unfaithful boyfriend picks up a hitchhiker who turns out to be a fugitive bank robber. Their chance encounter leads to an increasingly dangerous road trip involving stolen money, drug trafficking, and corrupt federal agents, as the unlikely pair find themselves caught in a criminal conspiracy.

Inventory

  • Opening credits robbery!
  • Missing point-blank with a shotgun!
  • Denture mishaps!
  • Throwing your motorcycle away, off a cliff, because it made a funny sound!
  • Oh shit, he actually killed them?!
  • This lady is WAY too trusting...!
  • It's OK, I brought my own cassette!
  • "He likes feet."(!)
  • Tip swindling!
  • Hot sauce in the EYES!
  • How in the world did she find him?!
  • Holy crap, that's Michael McDonald!
  • I'm worried my fiancé is cheating on me, so I'll just hook up with this random guy I met in a hotel!
  • Holy cow this is a confusing relationship!
  • "I can't shove an engagement ring up his butt over the phone!"
  • Cops with asthma!
  • Exploding cars!
  • Displaying bodies like you are Jason Voorhees!
  • Crooked cops!
  • "Screw the cheese, I want the rat!"
  • For somebody who never shot a gun before today, she has sniper-like precision!
  • "I'm a Judy Blume fan." "Prove it!" **Sex scene** - What?!
  • SkineMax-style sex scene with an ice cube!
  • Obligatory strip club scene!
  • Double-crosses!
  • "I hope there's no Gringos in Hell!"
  • M. Emmet Walsh's comb-over blowing...no...trying to escape...in the wind!
  • More double-crossings!
  • Opening a door by shooting the doorknob!
  • Toe sucking!
  • Self-sacrifices!
  • Let's just take the helicopter!
  • Fish-eye lens!
  • These bad guys seriously just kill anybody!
  • Was that...Will Ferrell?!
  • Morgan Fairchild?!

Best Quote

"Are you a doctor?" "No, but I fucked a few nurses."

Quick Review

Criminal Hearts is another mid-’90s Tarantino-inspired crime drama – think True Romance (which Tarantino DID write) mixed with Bonnie and Clyde, but not that good – but hey, it has that ’60s surf/beach movie guitar sound that every post-Pulp Fiction crime thriller used!

A few things stand out – the first is seeing MADtv alumnus Michael McDonald as not only a serious/grounded character, but one of the bad guys – is he wearing eye shadow?! So, you got Stuart from Mad TV / the ‘NOOoooOOooOOOooooo! StOooOOoooooOOooooOP!’ screaming-steamroller guy from Austin Powers and Blade Runner‘s M. Emmet Walsh as two VERY rogue FBI agents that straight up kill almost anybody they interact with. These guys were easily my favorite part of this one, it’s always fun when you can tell the actors playing the protagonists/villains are just enjoying the shit out of it – chewing dat scenery!

The other thing is our leading lady/eye candy, Amy Locane. She looked SO familiar, but I couldn’t place her at first – then it hit me, she was Allison in John Waters’ Cry-Baby and Kayla in Airheads! I decided to look her up on IMDb and went down a rabbit-hole learning she was incarcerated twice (but same crime?) for a vehicular manslaughter / DUI in 2010. Check out this crazy timeline –

In 2013, Locane was sentenced to three years for her involvement in a fatal 2010 DUI crash. She served approximately two and a half years and was released in 2015. But the prosecution had appealed her sentence, arguing it was improperly lenient. After years of appeals and multiple resentencings, she received an eight-year sentence in 2020 and was sent back to prison. Apparently, because her original sentence was still being challenged, double jeopardy protections didn’t prevent the increase. She ultimately served approximately six and a half years across both incarcerations before being released in December 2024.

So, she did some time, got out, started rebuilding her life, then years later, was sent BACK to prison after receiving a new eight-year sentence for the same crime! I legit have never heard of that kind of thing happening before, and would immediately think that double jeopardy/5th amendment would protect somebody from that kind of thing, but I am not a lawyer.

Back to the movie – it’s perfectly serviceable. It does what it sets out to do, tries to look cool in the process, and has some…odd scenes, such as one particular scene closer to the end of the movie. A police car pulls over Locane and sees that the car has multiple bullet holes and other signs of recent distress. He asks, “What’s with the car?” She replies, “Oh, I just got back from Mexico.” The cop replies, “Ah, that explains it!” and it’s never spoken of again. What the actual hell?! It almost feels like some throwaway line in a Troma film instead of the more grounded vibe this movie has.

Ultimately, Criminal Hearts is aggressively average. It’s got a couple of entertaining villains, some wonderfully questionable creative decisions, and enough double-crosses to convince itself it’s much smarter than it actually is. Perfectly watchable but also immediately forgettable, and not really worth taking up valuable shelf space.

Trivia

That WAS Will Ferrell! This was his first movie, and he is uncredited, playing a news anchor on the TV at the very end. Just practicing for Anchorman, obviously.

Verdict

Delete - No Retention Value

Bonuses

Nudity Bonus
Nudity Bonus!
Critical Salvage - Endangered, Out of Print, Hard to Find
Critical Salvage Bonus!

Availability Today

Physical: VHS / DVD (Region 2 (Germany))

Streaming: Unavailable anywhere currently / Not confirmed anywhere

Highest known release: DVD (standard definition)

Leave a Comment